LENDER DOES NOT HOLD MORTGAGE SECURITY IN TRUST FOR BORROWER: SUPREME COURT QUASHES FIR OVER ALLEGED USE OF LAND AS CROSS-COLLATERAL

INTRODUCTION
The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India recently delivered a landmark ruling clarifying the limits of criminal jurisdiction in commercial lending transactions and reinforcing the statutory protection available to financial institutions. In Edelweiss Asset Reconstruction Company Limited v. State of NCT of Delhi & Ors. (Criminal Appeal No. 4622 of 2026 with Criminal Appeal No. 4623 of 2026), a Two-Judge Bench comprising Hon’ble Justices Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta set aside a Delhi High Court Judgment and quashed a FIR registered by the Economic Offences Wing (EOW), New Delhi. The Apex Court held that a lender receiving a mortgage to secure a loan does not hold the mortgaged property in trust for the borrower or third-party land owners. The Court reaffirmed that civil monetary disputes and contractual revenue-share disagreements cannot be given an artificial cloak of criminality to exert pressure on secured creditors.
BRIEF FACTS
- The Complainants, who owned 24.1563 acres of land in Gurugram, Haryana, entered into collaboration agreements in 2012-2013 with Raheja Developers Limited (hereinafter referred to as ‘RDL’) to obtain licenses and develop a group housing project known as “Raheja Vanya”.
- On September 2, 2016, L&T Finance Limited (hereinafter referred to as ‘L&T’) sanctioned a loan facility of ₹450 crores to RDL, secured by mortgages over four distinct project lands, including the licensed portion of the Complainants’ land, along with project receivables.
- The Complainants subsequently executed a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) and a Backup Security Agreement (BSA) in October 2016, acknowledging the mortgage of the licensed land in favour of the Lender to secure the facility.
- In April 2018, L&T enhanced the loan facility to ₹620 crores without creating any additional mortgage charge on the Complainants’ licensed land. Later, on December 30, 2019, L&T assigned the loan account along with underlying securities to Edelweiss Asset Reconstruction Company Limited (EARC) under Section 5 of the SARFAESI Act.
- Alleging that RDL and the Lenders improperly cross-collateralized their land for other projects, issued unauthorized No-Objection Certificates (NOCs) to buyers and defaulted on their contractual revenue share of ₹17.7 crores, the Complainants lodged a written Complaint with the EOW in June 2022.
- The EOW conducted a thorough preliminary enquiry, examined documents and parties and closed the Complaint on November 29, 2022, concluding that no cognizable offence was disclosed as the matter pertained purely to a civil money recovery dispute.
- Despite the police Action Taken Report (ATR) recording that no cognizable offence was made out, the Chief Judicial Magistrate (CJM), Saket Courts, New Delhi, allowed an Application under Section 156(3) CrPC on January 15, 2025, directing the registration of an FIR without assigning specific reasons for overriding the ATR.
- Pursuant to the CJM’s Order, FIR No. 0005 of 2025 was registered under Sections 406, 409, 420 and 120B IPC. The High Court of Delhi dismissed the quashing petitions filed by L&T and EARC under Section 528 BNSS / Section 482 CrPC, leading to the present Appeals before the Supreme Court.
ISSUES OF LAW
The Apex Court primarily locked its focus onto three pivotal questions:
- Whether an order passed by a Magistrate under Section 156(3) CrPC directing the registration of a FIR reflects valid judicial application of mind when it overrides a police Action Taken Report (ATR), which concluded after preliminary enquiry that no cognizable offence was made out, without recording any reasons for disagreement.
- Whether allegations concerning the creation of mortgages, loan enhancements and non-payment of contractual revenue share disclose the essential legal ingredients of criminal breach of trust (Sections 406/409 IPC), cheating (Sections 415/420 IPC) or criminal conspiracy (Section 120B IPC) against institutional lenders and asset reconstruction companies.
- Whether alleged contraventions of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 (RERA) or breaches of commercial development agreements can form the foundation of criminal prosecution against financial institutions.
ANALYSIS OF THE JUDGMENT
Adopting a clear and definitive legal framework to prevent the abuse of the criminal justice system in commercial disputes, the Supreme Court laid down several vital principles:
- Requirement of Judicial Mind Under Section 156(3) CrPC & Police ATRs: The Court observed that while a Magistrate is not bound by an ATR submitted by the police following a preliminary enquiry, the report constitutes material evidence. If the Magistrate chooses to disagree with the police finding that no cognizable offence is disclosed, the order must explicitly state cogent reasons for doing so. Rejection of an ATR on a mere ipse dixit without recorded reasoning demonstrates a lack of judicial application of mind.
- Absence of Fiduciary Relationship or Entrustment (Sections 406/409 IPC): The Bench held that initial entrustment of property is a sine qua non for criminal breach of trust. A financial institution taking a mortgage to secure repayment of its own loan does not receive or hold the mortgaged property “in trust” or as a fiduciary. The relationship between a lender and a borrower (or a third-party security provider) is strictly that of creditor and debtor. Consequently, holding mortgage security does not constitute entrustment under Section 405 or Section 409 IPC.
- Lack of Deception at Inception & Protection of ARCs (Sections 415/420 IPC): The Court emphasized that cheating requires dishonest intention and fraudulent inducement at the very inception of the transaction. L&T made no false representations to the land owners and loan sanctions preceded the commercial MoU. Furthermore, EARC entered the picture only on December 30, 2019, as an assignee under Section 5 of the SARFAESI Act, years after the creation of the underlying agreements. EARC was a complete stranger to the initial transactions and could not be imputed with fraudulent intent at inception.
- Exclusive Regulatory Framework of RERA: The Apex Court clarified that obligations regarding project escrow accounts and fund deployments under RERA are statutory duties of the promoter, not the institutional lender. Pursuant to Section 80 of the RERA Act, offences under the statute can only be taken cognizance of upon a written complaint by the RERA Authority itself and private criminal FIRs under the IPC cannot be sustained on alleged RERA non-compliances.
- Abuse of Criminal Process for Commercial Money Recovery: Examining the sequence of events, the Court noted that the Complainants had actively pursued civil, arbitral and insolvency remedies. A settlement email dated August 24, 2022, offering to drop all criminal complaints in exchange for ₹80 crores, clearly established that the criminal prosecution was initiated with an ulterior motive to exert pressure and enforce monetary demands.
Aniket Kumar Parcha
Legal Associate
The Indian Lawyer & Allied Services
EDITOR’S COMMENTS
Reaffirming that commercial lenders cannot be drawn into criminal litigation over developer defaults and money recovery claims, the Supreme Court provided robust legal protection to regulated financial institutions and asset reconstruction entities. Consequently, the Apex Court set aside the Delhi High Court Judgment, set aside the CJM Saket Order and completely quashed FIR No. 0005 of 2025 and all connected proceedings against L&T Finance Limited and Edelweiss Asset Reconstruction Company Limited. This Judgement sends a powerful message across the banking and corporate sector: commercial disputes arising out of security priority, loan enhancements and contractual revenue shares belong strictly within civil, arbitral or statutory recovery forums and the criminal law machinery cannot be weaponized as a tool for financial leverage.
SUSHILA RAM VARMA
Advocate & Chief Consultant
The Indian Lawyer & Allied Services
Please log onto our YouTube channel, The Indian Lawyer Legal Tips, to learn about various aspects of the law. Our latest Video, titled “Can Adoptive Mothers Take Maternity Leave? Shocking Truth!” can be viewed at the link below:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZqgGRVZkr4g


































Leave a Reply