November 21, 2026 In Advovacy, Blog, Consultancy

ROAD SAFETY CANNOT COME AT THE COST OF PROCEDURAL JUSTICE

INTRODUCTION

In Re: Phalodi Accident v. National Highways Authority of India & Ors., 2026 INSC 1243, decided on 18 November 2026, the Supreme Court of India, comprising Justices Vikram Nath and Aparesh Kumar Singh, examined the scope of its earlier directions concerning the removal of unauthorised encroachments along National Highways.

The Judgment examines whether the Authorities can rely on directions issued in the interest of road safety to demolish disputed structures without first ascertaining the rights of the affected persons and following the procedure established by law. The Court emphasised that measures aimed at ensuring public safety must be implemented in accordance with statutory requirements and principles of procedural fairness.

 

BRIEF FACTS

The present proceedings arose from the suo motu Writ Petition initiated by the Supreme Court following road accidents at Phalodi, Rajasthan and other places, raising serious concerns regarding highway safety and unauthorised encroachments.

By an Order dated 13 April 2026, the Court issued several directions to the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI), State Public Works Departments and other authorities for identifying and removing encroachments within the Right of Way of National Highways. These directions also prohibited new commercial structures within the Right of Way and required the constitution of District Highway Safety Task Forces.

Following these directions, NHAI and other authorities initiated action against structures alleged to be encroachments. Several affected land Owners and Occupants approached the Supreme Court through Interlocutory Applications, seeking clarification and protection against proposed demolition. They contended that their structures stood on privately owned land, that the demarcation of the Right of Way was disputed and that the authorities had not properly determined their ownership claims or followed the prescribed legal procedure. Some Applicants also sought acquisition of their land and compensation, wherever required.

NHAI, on the other hand, maintained that the proposed action was necessary to implement the Supreme Court’s directions and that Notices had been issued under the Control of National Highways (Land and Traffic) Act, 2002. The Applicants complaints were therefore considered together through a common Judgment.

 

ISSUES OF LAW

  • Whether the Supreme Court’s directions dated 13 April 2026 authorised the demolition of structures without an independent determination of whether they constituted unauthorised encroachments?
  • Whether NHAI could remove disputed structures without complying with the procedure prescribed under Section 26 of the Control of National Highways (Land and Traffic) Act, 2002?
  • Whether persons claiming ownership or lawful occupation of land adjoining National Highways were entitled to an opportunity to establish their claims before coercive action was undertaken?

 

ANALYSIS OF THE JUDGMENT

The Supreme Court began by clarifying the scope of its earlier directions dated Order 13 April 2026. It observed that those directions were issued to address the larger problem of highway safety and the removal of unlawful encroachments. However, the Court had not examined the ownership, boundaries or legal status of each individual property that might subsequently become the subject of action by the authorities. Consequently, the earlier directions could not be treated as a conclusive determination that every disputed structure was an unauthorised encroachment.

The Court drew an important distinction between directing the removal of encroachments and determining whether a particular structure actually constituted an encroachment. While the authorities were under an obligation to remove unauthorised structures, that obligation did not dispense with the requirement to establish the legal status of the property concerned. The directions could not confer powers beyond those available under the applicable statutory framework.

The Court placed particular emphasis on Section 26 of the Control of National Highways (Land and Traffic) Act, 2002. Sub-sections (2) to (6) of Section 26 prescribe a mechanism involving the issuance of notice identifying the highway land, an opportunity to submit representations and consideration of the explanation offered by the affected person. Referring to Gyan Prakash v. Union of India and Others, the Court reiterated the importance of following this procedure in accordance with the principles of natural justice. Although subsections (7) and (8) of Section 26 provide for removal without prior notice in specified circumstances, the exercise of such powers must satisfy the statutory conditions.

The Court also addressed the competing claims concerning ownership and demarcation. It observed that a mere assertion of ownership cannot prevent authorities from exercising their statutory powers. Equally, an assertion by NHAI that a structure falls within the Right of Way cannot substitute for the determination required under law, particularly where the demarcation itself is disputed. Such disputes may require examination of revenue records, acquisition proceedings, survey reports and other relevant documents.

Considering the nature of these individual grievances, the Court held that the jurisdictional High Courts were better placed to examine the relevant records and determine the legality of the proposed action. It therefore granted liberty to the Applicants to approach their respective High Courts for adjudication of their claims. Importantly, the Court clarified that it had expressed no opinion on the merits of the ownership claims or the legality of NHAI’s actions.

 

CONCLUSION

The Judgment reinforces that administrative action, even when undertaken in pursuit of an important public objective such as road safety, must remain within the limits prescribed by law. The Supreme Court did not dilute its earlier directions for removing unauthorised encroachments rather, it clarified that their implementation must be consistent with statutory safeguards and the rights of affected persons. By preserving interim protection against demolition until the respective High Courts decide the grievances, the Court sought to balance the public interest in safer highways with the individual’s right to a fair hearing. Ultimately, the decision makes clear that the objective of removing encroachments cannot justify bypassing due process.

 

TRISHMA KASHYAP

Legal Associate

The Indian Lawyer & Allied Services

 

 

Please log onto our YouTube channel, The Indian Lawyer Legal Tips, to learn about various aspects of the law. Our latest Video, titled “Can Adoptive Mothers Take Maternity Leave? Shocking Truth!” can be viewed at the link below:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZqgGRVZkr4g

 

 

 

Leave a Reply